1928 - James MacPhee (Community)
(Chief from August of 1928, when the department was formed, to 1929)
1929 - Henry Pulsch (Port Monmouth) (first officially elected Chief)
1930 - Adam Eddichoffer (East Keansburg)
1931 - David Schnoor (Belford Independent)
1932 - William Scott (Middletown #1)
1933 - George Kaney (River Plaza)
1934 - Schuyler Sickles (Navesink)
1935 - William Meyer (Brevent Park)
1936 - Joseph Smith (Belford Engine)
1937 - Howard A. Mallen (Community)
1938 - Eugene M. Reardon (East Keansburg)
1939 - Joseph Wacker (Port Monmouth)
1940 - Stanley Cook (Belford Independent)
1941 - Arthur Sodon (Middletown #1)
1942 - Norman Scattergood (River Plaza)
1943 - Henery Carney (Lincroft) (called into service during term)
1943 - James Hennehane (Lincroft) (completed Carney's term)
1944 - Donald D. Johnson (Navesink) (called in service during term)
1944 - Donald Quackenbush (Navesink) (completed Johnson's term)
1945 - Joseph Supienski (Brevent Park)
1946 - Dirk Hoffman (Belford Engine)
1947 - Morris Josephs (Community)
1948 - John Mayer (East Keansburg)
1949 - Edward Freibott (Port Monmouth)
1950 - J. Harry Bennett (Belford Independent)
1951 - Gabriel Simplicio (Middletown #1)
1952 - John Fowler (River Plaza) (died in office)
1952 - William Stobo (River Plaza) (completed Fowler's term)
1953 - Gerard Dominion (Lincroft) (died in the line of duty)
1953 - Garrett Corson (Lincroft) (completed Dominion's term)
1954 - William S. Pape (Navesink)
1955 - David LaRue(Brevent Park)
1956 - Joesph Munch (Belford Engine)
1957 - William Ast (Community)
1958 - William Vitalli (East Keansburg)
1959 - Newton Mallet (Port Monmouth)
1960 - Elwood Seeley (Belford Independent)
1961 - Harlan Hogan (Middletown #1)
1962 - Norman Long Jr. (River Plaza)
1963 - John C. Fowler (Lincroft)
1964 - Henry Lutz Jr. (Old Village)
1965 - John Dashkavich (Navesink)
1966 - Alvin Maxson (Brevent Park)
1967 - Albert White (Belford Engine)
1968 - Neil Corbet (Community)
1969 - Harold Cruse (East Keansburg)
1970 - Fred Beam (Port Monmouth)
1971 - Joseph Hennelly (Belford Independent)
1972 - William Kane (Middletown #1)
1973 - W. Irwin Hendricks (River Plaza)
1974 - George Richdale (Lincroft)
1975 - Jeffrey Mackey (Old Village)
1976 - Harold E. Salenger (Navesink)
1977 - Chester (Jake) Supienski (Brevent Park)
1978 - Charles Widmaier (Belford Engine)
1979 - George Gremmenger (Community)
1980 - Daniel F. Kelly (East Keansburg)
1981 - William B. Miller (Port Monmouth)
1982 - Charles Wilson (Belford Independent)
1983 - Richard O'Shaughnessy (Middletown #1)
1984 - John Fricker (River Plaza)
1985 - Austin B. McKnight (Lincroft)
1986 - Bruce George (Old Village)
1987 - Russel W. Mount Jr. (Navesink)
1988 - Robert Grimm Sr. (Brevent Park)
1989 - Louis Aquilla (Belford Engine)
1990 - Gary Corbet (Community)
1991 - John Bayard (East Keansburg)
1992 - Charles Rogers III (Port Monmouth)
1993 - Thomas Amato (Belford Independent)
1994 - Stanley A. Midose (Middletown #1)
1995 - Gary J. Homefield (River Plaza)
1996 - Dennis Fowler (Lincroft)
1997 - Michael Lee (Old Village)
1998 - J. Timothy Sodon (Navesink)
1999 - Barry Grimm (Brevent Park)
2000 - James Naclerio (Belford Engine)
2001 - Douglas Corbet (Community)
2002 - Kevin Kane (East Keansburg)
2003 - William Gilmartin (Port Monmouth)
2004 - William J. Hibell (Belford Independent)
2005 - Greg Papailiou (Middletown #1)
2006 - Peter Lucyk (River Plaza)
2007 - William Kenelly (Lincroft)
2008 - Vincent Falci (Old Village)
2009 - John Kardel (Navesink)